The highly anticipated film Wicked hit theaters on November 22, 2024. The iconic Broadway musical’s adaptation to the big screen yielded mixed reactions. Some praised the stunning visuals and impressive performances while others criticized some of the changes to the original, such as the pacing and the decision to make the film two parts. I myself saw the live Broadway version years ago, and had high expectations for such a beloved story. The question is if the movie measures up to the legacy of Wicked.
The film’s massive press tour generated much excitement, especially with a star-studded cast including Ariana Grande as Glinda and Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba. The connection between Grande and Erivo is undeniable. Often found on the brink of tears throughout interviews, the chemistry between the leads is palpable. Despite this, many still felt the cast could not fully live up to the depth of the stage production. Grande in particular received backlash for her pursuit of a character that is so different from her brand. Regardless of the mixed reviews, the film has undeniably captured the public’s attention, cementing Wicked as a pop culture phenomenon once again.
One of the most shocking moments in the film was when Kristen Chenoweth and Idina Menzel, the original Glinda and Elphaba, made surprise appearances. The well-kept secret was a heartfelt nod to longtime fans. To the dismay of some of these fans, the movie comes in two parts, with the first film coming to a close at the end of Act 1 and the second expected to be released in fall of 2025. While this decision leaves audiences with anticipation for the sequel, it also means that much of the complicated narrative is left unexplored, making the first film feel somewhat incomplete. Therefore, it does not quite replicate the emotional depth of the entirety of the Broadway production. Fans of the Broadway version will likely appreciate the film’s grandeur, but may be unsatisfied without the intricate character development and plot-twists of Act 2.
Of course, the musical is not the original source material; it’s based on Gregory Maguire’s 1995 novel, which offers a darker backstory on the characters of the Wizard of Oz. The book reimagines characters such as Elphaba, the Wicked Witch of the West and a misunderstood hero, as morally ambiguous characters. He also explores Glinda, the Good Witch, and her complex journey to a position of power, as well as how Dorothy’s side-kicks become made of straw or tin. While the musical is heavily influenced by Maguire’s narrative, it simplifies some of the themes to focus more on friendship rather than ethics, allowing for a lighter theatrical experience. The Wicked film creatively blends the worlds of the original Oz, Maguire’s reimagining, and the musical.
Personally, my expectations were exceeded by the Wicked movie. Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo were incredible at telling the complicated tale of Glinda and Elphaba. The visuals were stunning and the score was exceptional. As much as I enjoyed the film, however, nothing can truly compare to the magic of seeing the show live on Broadway. The quiet in the cinema during “Defying Gravity” did not compare to the deafening silence of the theater as smoke filled the room and Elphaba levitated before my eyes. That moment, when the audience collectively held their breath, felt like pure theater magic. I was in awe of the live performances and moved by the intimacy that trumps any cinematic adaptation. Meghan Roskopf, a sophomore, also saw the musical live on Broadway years ago. She offers a different take: “it was so amazing to be able to see both the Broadway and the movie version! There were so many ways the movie was different, such as special effects that made the story come to life. I think I prefer the movie version because it was up close and easy to understand, as well as the pop culture that came along with the movie.” Clearly, the movie does justice to the live rendition. While the Wicked film was impressive, for me, the Broadway experience is irreplaceable.
Overall, the Wicked film is a captivating reimagining that brings the story of the beloved musical to life. Personally, I preferred the live performance compared to the screen adaptation. Nonetheless, Wicked is a great watch for old and new fans, and is certainly worthy of the Broadway legacy.
